RFC 1995, "Incremental Zone Transfer in DNS", August 1996Source of RFC: dnsind (int)
See Also: RFC 1995 w/ inline errata
Errata ID: 3197
Publication Format(s) : TEXT
Reported By: Alfred Hoenes
Date Reported: 2012-04-18
Verifier Name: Brian Haberman
Date Verified: 2012-05-01
Section 4, pg.3 says:
| RRs in the incremental transfer messages may be partial. That is, if a single RR of multiple RRs of the same RR type changes, only the changed RR is transferred.
It should say:
| RRsets in the incremental transfer messages may be partial. That is, | if a single RR out of multiple RRs of the same RR type at the same | owner name and CLASS changes, only the changed RR is transferred.
DNS resource records (RRs) are always transferred as integral
entities in the DNS protocol, and IXFR is no exception for this
rule. So there never are partial RRs in any IXFR response packets.
However, as indicated more precisely in the adjusted text above,
it is intended that partial _RRsets_ are carried in IXFR responses;
unchanged RRs are not sent inside incremental response messages.
The above issue has been identified by the submitter in 2008,
but no Errata have been filed so far. However, it already had
been observed in 1999 by Andreas Gustafsson, who, in the context of
the work on RFC 1995bis, recently has provided the DNSEXT WG access
to a privately archived DNSIND mailing list thread on RFC 1995,
in which such issues have been discussed in November 1999.
For the record, the technical issues in RFC 1995 that can be
addressed by Errata Notes are now being submitted this way.