RFC Errata
RFC 4874, "Exclude Routes - Extension to Resource ReserVation Protocol-Traffic Engineering (RSVP-TE)", April 2007
Source of RFC: ccamp (rtg)See Also: RFC 4874 w/ inline errata
Errata ID: 3572
Status: Verified
Type: Editorial
Publication Format(s) : TEXT
Reported By: Dhruv Dhody
Date Reported: 2013-03-28
Verifier Name: Adrian Farrel
Date Verified: 2013-03-29
Section 1.2 says:
area A area B area C
<-------------------> <----------------> <------------------>
Ingress-----A1----A2----AB1----B1----B2----BC1----C1----C2----Egress
^ \ / | \ / | \ /
| \ / | \ / | \ /
| A3----------A4--AB2--B3--------B4--BC2--C3----------C4
| ^ ^
| | |
| | |
| | ERO: (C3-strict, C4-strict,
| | Egress-strict)
| | XRO: Not needed
| |
| ERO: (B3-strict, B4-strict, BC2-strict, Egress-loose)
| XRO: (BC1, C1, C2)
|
ERO: (A3-strict, A4-strict, AB2-strict, Egress-loose)
XRO: (AB1, B1, B2, BC1, C1, C2, Egress)
It should say:
area A area B area C
<-------------------> <----------------> <------------------>
Ingress-----A1----A2----AB1----B1----B2----BC1----C1----C2----Egress
^ \ / | \ / | \ /
| \ / | \ / | \ /
| A3----------A4--AB2--B3--------B4--BC2--C3----------C4
| ^ ^
| | |
| | |
| | ERO: (C3-strict, C4-strict,
| | Egress-strict)
| | XRO: Not needed
| |
| ERO: (B3-strict, B4-strict, BC2-strict, Egress-loose)
| XRO: (BC1, C1, C2)
|
ERO: (A3-strict, A4-strict, AB2-strict, Egress-loose)
XRO: (AB1, B1, B2, BC1, C1, C2)
Notes:
The figure incorrectly shows the longest XRO to include the Egress as well.
The text in the RFC is correct - "....so the ERO and XRO signaled at Ingress could be (A3-strict, A4-strict, AB2-strict, Egress-loose) and (AB1, B1, B2, BC1, C1, C2), respectively. "
The editorial error exist in the figure.