AUTH48 status page for C442

Cluster Details


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ace-oauth-authz-46 (RFC-to-be 9200)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2022-02-28. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
L. Seitz Y 2022-03-28
G. Selander Y 2022-03-31
E. Wahlstroem Y 2022-04-13
S. Erdtman Y 2022-04-13
H. Tschofenig Y 2022-04-13
AD - B. Kaduk and P. Wouters Y 2022-04-13
IANA Y 2022-04-19

** This document is part of Cluster C442, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2022-02-28: Questions sent to authors. Requested AD reply on 2 questions. Also, one cluster-wide question was sent. 2022-03-03: Response received. Author submitted updated XML file. 2022-03-08: Updated files and follow-up questions sent. Reminder sent to ADs. 2022-03-10: Author submitted updated XML file from GitHub. 2022-03-16: Updated files sent. Reminder sent to ADs. 2022-03-17: Response received. 2022-03-24: Updated files sent. AD approval requested. 2022-03-31: Updated files sent. Reminder sent to ADs. 2022-04-07: Ben Kaduk sent AD approval and additional updates. 2022-04-12: Updated files sent. Requested that Paul also send approval as the current Sec AD. 2022-04-15: IANA updates requested. Pub note (2022-04-25): We will wait for RFC-to-be 9203 to complete AUTH48 before moving forward.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ace-oauth-params-16 (RFC-to-be 9201)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2022-02-28. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
L. Seitz Y 2022-04-04
AD - P. Wouters Y 2022-04-20
IANA Y 2022-04-25

** This document is part of Cluster C442, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2022-02-28: questions sent to author. Also, one cluster-wide question was sent. 2022-03-03: Response received. Author submitted updated xml file. 2022-03-07: Author submitted xml file with changes. 2022-03-07: Updated files sent. 1 remaining unanswered query. Additional clarification question about the use of sent. 2022-03-07: Response received. All questions answered. 2022-03-08: Author requested a delay in publishing due to "an inconsistency in how examples are represented in CBOR diagnostic notation". 2022-03-10: Response received. 2022-03-16: Two follow-up questions sent. 2022-03-17: Response received. 2022-03-24: Updated files sent. AD approval requested. 2022-03-31: Updated files sent. Reminder sent to ADs. 2022-04-12: Reminder sent to ADs. 2022-04-19: Reminder sent to Paul for AD approval. 2022-04-21: IANA registry updates requested. 2022-04-25: We will wait for RFC-to-be 9203 to complete AUTH48 before moving forward.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ace-dtls-authorize-18 (RFC-to-be 9202)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2022-02-28. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
S. Gerdes Y 2022-04-01
O. Bergmann Y 2022-03-14
C. Bormann Y 2022-03-24
G. Selander Y 2022-04-01
L. Seitz Y 2022-04-04
AD - P. Wouters Y 2022-04-16
IANA Y 2022-04-19

** This document is part of Cluster C442, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2022-02-28: questions sent to authors. also, one cluster-wide question was sent. 2022-03-08: reminder sent. 2022-03-14: updated XML file received. 2022-03-18: updated files sent. AD approval requested. 2022-03-18: AD sent additional nits. 2022-03-24: updated files sent. AD approval requested. 2022-03-31: reminder sent to authors and ADs. 2022-04-12: reminder sent to ADs. 2022-04-19: IANA registry updates requested. 2022-04-25: We will wait for RFC-to-be 9203 to complete AUTH48 before moving forward.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ace-oscore-profile-19 (RFC-to-be 9203)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2022-02-28. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
F. Palombini Y 2022-04-26
L. Seitz Y 2022-04-04
G. Selander Y 2022-04-25
M. Gunnarsson Y 2022-04-27
AD: P. Wouters (sections listed in the notes) Y 2022-04-16
IANA - [IANA #1227727] Y 2022-03-15
IANA - Section 9.3 Y 2022-04-27
AD - P. Wouters N  

** This document is part of Cluster C442, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2022-02-28: Questions sent to authors. Also, one cluster-wide question was sent (note that the authors have addressed this AQ - they will use ). 2022-03-14: Response received. 2022-03-15: Updates to IANA registry completed. 2022-03-17: AD approval requested for Sections 3.1, 3.2, 4.1, and 4.2 and for no change to the term "master". 2022-03-18: AD response received - further updates were requested by the AD. 2022-03-19: Response received. 2022-03-22: Response received. The RPC asked the AD to confirm his approval of the requested changes that were incorporated, in addition to the changes made to Sections 3.1, 3.2, 4.1, and 4.2. 2022-03-23: Received an updated XML file from G. Selander (per discussion on the cluster-wide AQ thread). The changes were incorporated, and the AD was asked to approve the updates (in addition to the ones already pending). 2022-04-04: Approval from L. Seitz received. 2022-04-06: Sent reminder to respond to the ADs (Ben/Paul). 2022-04-13: Sent reminder to Paul (AD) to approve the technical changes. 2022-04-16: AD approval received. 2022-04-22: Sent reminder to authors to respond. 2022-04-25: Approval from G. Selander received. 2022-04-26: Approval from F. Palombini received. 2022-04-27: Approval from M. Gunnarsson received. Asked AD to approve the addition to the Acknowledgements section) - AD approval received. Asked IANA to update their registry to remove "Original Specification" in Section 9.3 [IANA #1230014]. IANA update completed. 2022-04-27: Paul Wouters approved updates to the Acknowledgements section. 2022-05-05: rerequested Paul's approval for author-proposed changes to the normative references to RFCs-to-be 9052 and 9053. --- Pub note: AD confirmed we are waiting for normative dependency on RFCs 9052 and 9053 (rather than changing the references)


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ace-aif-07 (RFC-to-be 9237)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2022-04-22. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Bormann Y 2022-04-28
IANA Y 2022-04-28
AD - P. Wouters Y 2022-04-29

** This document is part of Cluster C442, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2022-04-22: Questions sent to author. 2022-04-24: Reply received (all questions addressed). 2022-04-25: Posted updated files and sent several followup questions. 2022-04-27: Reply received. 2022-04-28: Posted updated files and sent one followup question. 2022-04-28: Followup question addressed. 2022-04-28: Requested AD approval of addition to Fig 4 (above editorial). Requested that IANA update media type registrations to match edited document. 2022-04-28: IANA update complete. 2022-04-29: AD approval received. PUB note: This document references both RFC-to-be 9110 (normative) and RFC-to-be 9200 (informative), so it will be published at the same time as those documents. As of 2022-04-29, both are in in AUTH48-DONE, waiting for the final documents in cluster 430 to complete AUTH48.


Instructions to author(s):

Please see the AUTH48 notification email from the RFC Editor that contains links to the edited files and other information. To send your approval of or changes for a specific document, please Reply All to the message for the given RFC-to-be in question.

If cluster-wide questions were received, please Reply All to that email so each of the relevant parties may partake in the decision process.

See information below for the status of documents within the cluster that are in AUTH48.

When all approvals for a given document have been received, publication will continue once its normative references have completed the AUTH48 process as well. Upon publication of the cluster, this AUTH48 status page will no longer be available.