AUTH48 status page for C238

Cluster Details


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-overview-19 (RFC-to-be 8825)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-29. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
H. Alvestrand Y 2020-11-21
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-08: First approval from author. 2020-11-04: Asked author and AD to review and approve usage of RFC 2119/8174 key words, per "[C238] [Author Action Requested] Cluster-wide question regarding the RFC 2119/8174 keywords paragraph" email dated 21 July 2020. 2020-11-21: Author reviewed the usage of key words in this document: "This document is RFC 8174 compatible. My approval stands." 2020-12-03: AD approval (re. the usage of key words) received.


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-security-12 (RFC-to-be 8826)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-29. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
E. Rescorla N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-29: Questions sent to author.


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-security-arch-20 (RFC-to-be 8827)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-29. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
E. Rescorla N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-29: Questions sent to author.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-ip-handling-12 (RFC-to-be 8828)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-01. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
J. Uberti Y 2020-07-24

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-01: Instructions for completing AUTH48 sent to the author. 2020-07-10: Reminder to reply sent to the author. 2020-07-17: Reminder to reply sent to the author. 2020-07-24: Response received. 2020-07-30: Asked author about including keywords. 2020-08-05: Reminded the author to respond. 2020-08-06: Response received.


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-jsep-26 (RFC-to-be 8829)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-06. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
J. Uberti N  
C. Jennings N  
E. Rescorla, Ed. N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-06: questions sent to the authors AUTH48 being handled in GitHub (experimental process) 2020-11-19: 2119/8174 question: Cullen indicates we should use 8174, but he wants to review use of any lowercase keywords in the doc. Issue opened in GitHub to address this; see .


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-msid-17 (RFC-to-be 8830)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-13. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
H. Alvestrand Y 2020-08-28
AD: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-09-11

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-13: questions sent to the author 2020-07-20: reminder sent 2020-07-23: response received. 2020-07-30: reminder to respond sent. 2020-07-06: additional questions asked. 2020-08-17: reminder to respond sent. 2020-08-26: response received. 2020-08-28: response received. AD approval requested for Sections 2 and 3.1. 2020-09-04: sent reminder to AD to respond. 2020-09-11: sent reminder to AD to respond. Response received. 2020-11-23: asked about updating the date/url for the WebRTC and W3C.CR references; author approved the updates. 2020-12-03: asked author to review 2119/8174 update


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-data-channel-13 (RFC-to-be 8831)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-18. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Jesup Y 2020-09-30
S. Loreto Y 2020-07-08
M. Tuexen Y 2020-07-06
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-18: questions sent to the authors. 2020-07-27: reminder sent to R. Jesup. 2020-08-13: reminder sent to R. Jesup. Open question regarding use of 2119/8174 key words paragraph. 2020-09-17: Question re. 2119 vs. 2119+8174 boilerplate addressed (reviewed by Michael Tuexen). 2020-11-04: Asked for AD approval re. 2119+8174 boilerplate, per email dated 21 July 2020 (Subject line: [C238] [Author Action Requested] Cluster-wide question regarding the RFC 2119/8174 keywords paragraph). 2020-12-03: AD approval (re. usage of key words) received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-data-protocol-09 (RFC-to-be 8832)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-18. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Jesup Y 2020-10-20
S. Loreto Y 2020-07-08
M. Tuexen Y 2020-07-07
AD: (Murray Kucherawy) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-18: questions sent to the authors. 2020-06-03: questions resolved. 2020-06-23: Christer Holmberg reviewed this document and noted that all looks good. 2020-08-13: reminder sent to R. Jessup. Open question regarding use of 2119/8174 key words paragraph. 2020-09-17: Question re. 2119 vs. 2119+8174 boilerplate addressed (reviewed by Michael Tuexen). 2020-11-04: Asked for AD approval re. 2119+8174 boilerplate, per email dated 21 July 2020 (Subject line: [C238] [Author Action Requested] Cluster-wide question regarding the RFC 2119/8174 keywords paragraph). 2020-12-03: AD approval (re. usage of key words) received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-alpn-04 (RFC-to-be 8833)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-25. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
M. Thomson Y 2020-06-30
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-25: questions sent to the author. 2020-05-26: author responded. 2020-05-29: updated files posted; question about reference to HTML5 remains open 2020-06-09: reminder sent 2020-06-10: HTML5 reference listing resolved and updated. 2020-10-23: 2119/8174 question still pending. Sent an email. 2020-10-25: Martin Thomson confirmed that everything "2119/8174" is OK. 2020-11-04: Asked for AD approval re. 2119+8174 boilerplate, per email dated 21 July 2020 (Subject line: [C238] [Author Action Requested] Cluster-wide question regarding the RFC 2119/8174 key words paragraph). 2020-12-03: AD approval (re. usage of key words) received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-rtp-usage-26 (RFC-to-be 8834)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-29. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Perkins Y 2020-07-01
M. Westerlund Y 2020-11-24
J. Ott Y 2020-07-01
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-07-23

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-29: questions sent to the authors. 2020-06-12: Asked for AD approval re. removal of a sentence. 2020-06-30: AD approval received. 2020-07-22: Question re. 2119 vs. 2119+8174 boilerplate addressed by Colin Perkins. 2020-07-23: Requested AD approval for update to boilerplate language. 2020-07-23: AD approval received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-transports-17 (RFC-to-be 8835)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-01. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
H. Alvestrand Y 2020-06-24
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-01: questions sent to the author. 2020-06-24: Requested AD approval for addition of RFC 8842 to the Normative References section. 2020-06-24: AD approval received. 2020-10-23: 2119/8174 question still pending. Sent an email. 2020-10-23: Harald reviewed the document again and confirmed that everything is OK. 2020-11-04: Asked for AD approval regarding cluster-wide question regarding the RFC 2119/8174 key words paragraph. 2020-12-03: AD approval (re. usage of key words) received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rmcat-cc-requirements-09 (RFC-to-be 8836)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-02. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Jesup Y 2020-10-19
Z. Sarker, Ed. Y 2020-06-15
AD (Martin Duke) Y 2020-11-09

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-15: Requested AD approval of removal of a bullet item in Section 2. 2020-06-19: AD approval received. 2020-09-16: The topic of "key words" (RFCs 2119 and 8174) has come up. Asked AD for feedback re. any related updates that might be made. 2020-10-20: Update (FYI): The "RFCs 2119 and 8174" question is still pending a review and response from Zahed, per Martin. Martin will approve after he can review Zahed's updates (if any). 2020-11-09: Zahed applied some updates on 7 November, and Martin approved them.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-tsvwg-rtcweb-qos-18 (RFC-to-be 8837)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-08. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
P. Jones Y 2020-06-30
S. Dhesikan Y 2020-07-23
C. Jennings Y 2020-07-22
D. Druta Y 2020-06-30
AD: Martin Duke Y 2020-07-24

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-22: Question re. 2119 vs. 2119+8174 boilerplate addressed (reviewed by David Black). 2020-07-23: Requested AD approval for change to boilerplate language. 2020-07-24: AD approval received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ice-trickle-21 (RFC-to-be 8838)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-08. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
E. Ivov Y 2020-05-14
J. Uberti Y 2020-05-31
P. Saint-Andre Y 2020-05-16
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-08: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-12: responses received. 2020-05-14: response received. 2020-05-16: response received. 2020-05-18: response received. 2020-05-27: reminder sent for Justin to respond. 2020-05-31: response received. 2020-06-01: response received. 2020-11-09: hyphenated 'peer-reflexive' and 'server-reflexive' to match RFC-to-be 8839; asked authors to approve. 2020-11-19: Peter replied to 2119/8174 question [Note for RFC Editor: did not replace 5389 with 8489]


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-ice-sip-sdp-39 (RFC-to-be 8839)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-18. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
M. Petit-Huguenin Y 2020-05-26
S. Nandakumar Y 2020-05-26
C. Holmberg Y 2020-05-20
A. Keränen Y 2020-06-02
R. Shpount Y 2020-05-20

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-18: questions sent to authors.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-trickle-ice-sip-18 (RFC-to-be 8840)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-18. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
E. Ivov Y 2020-05-19
T. Stach Y 2020-05-20
E. Marocco Y 2020-05-18
C. Holmberg Y 2020-07-10
IANA update Y 2020-05-19
IANA Y 2020-07-10

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-18: sent questions to authors. Sent minor update to IANA. Author response received. 2020-05-19: response received. 2020-05-20: response received. 2020-05-25: response received to cluster-wide questions. 2020-06-11: asked follow-up question re: quote marks. 2020-06-12: response received. 2020-06-17: asked follow-up question re: "a=". 2020-06-23: response received. 2020-07-07: asked authors to confirm keeping or deleting "a=". 2020-07-08: response received. 2020-07-09: additional questions asked. 2020-07-10: response received. Requested that IANA update their registry [IANA #1174079]. 2020-07-13: IANA updates are complete.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-sctp-sdp-26 (RFC-to-be 8841)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-09-22
R. Shpount Y 2020-05-07
S. Loreto Y 2020-05-12
G. Camarillo Y 2020-05-07
Area Director: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-10-08
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-05: reply received. 2020-05-12: added ticket #520 regarding "SE-" in postal address (https://trac.tools.ietf.org/tools/xml2rfc/trac/ticket/520). 2020-06-09: ticket #520 was fixed in release v2.45.0. the files have been remade and reposted. 2020-08-12: added sentence to Section 4.4.2. 2020-08-14: requested AD approval of changes to Section 13.1. 2020-12-03: Christer approved 8174 keywords paragraph


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-dtls-sdp-32 (RFC-to-be 8842)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-05-13
R. Shpount Y 2020-05-13

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-05: reply received. 2020-05-05: sent an additional question. 2020-05-06: reply received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-sdp-bundle-negotiation-54 (RFC-to-be 8843)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-05-07
H. Alvestrand Y 2020-05-07
C. Jennings Y 2020-05-08
AD: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-05-18

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-05: response received. 2020-05-07: response received. 2020-05-08: response received. Requested AD approval of changes to the Abstract. 2020-05-18: Reminder to respond sent to AD. Response received. 2020-07-29: Asked the authors about making the capitalization consistent for SDP Offer/Answer; updated to lowercase for consistency.


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-mmusic-sdp-uks-07 (RFC-to-be 8844)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-22. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
M. Thomson Y 2020-11-18
E. Rescorla N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-22: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-25: Thomson responded with feedback. 2020-05-26: document updated. 2020-06-05: reminder sent. 2020-06-15: reminder sent. 2020-06-23: reminder sent. 2020-07-13: reminder sent. 2020-08-26: reminder sent. 2020-09-14: reminder sent. 2020-09-24: reminder sent. 2020-10-06: reminder sent. 2020-10-27: reminder sent. 2020-11-05: reminder sent. 2020-11-18: approval received from Thomson. 2020-11-24: response received from Rescorla. 2020-12-03: reminder sent.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-framework-25 (RFC-to-be 8845)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-23. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
M. Duckworth, Ed. Y 2020-07-10
A. Pepperell Y 2020-07-17
S. Wenger Y 2020-07-10
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba Y 2020-07-16
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-23: questions sent to authors. 2020-06-24: response received. 2020-06-29: response received. 2020-07-01: response received. 2020-07-08: response received. 2020-07-09: response received. 2020-07-10: request from author of RFC-to-be 8848 to move "CLUE" to the terms list. Requested AD approval for “CIF" being updated to “352x288p30”. 2020-07-16: sent reminder to respond. AD approval received. 2020-07-17: response received. 2020-07-20: Stephen Wenger indicates that 8174 text is appropriate. 2020-09-04: asked additional terminology question re: Media Stream vs. media stream


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-data-model-schema-17 (RFC-to-be 8846)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-23. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Presta Y 2020-07-16
S. Pietro Romano Y 2020-07-14

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-23: questions sent to authors. 2020-06-30: reminder to respond sent to authors. 2020-07-06: response received. 2020-07-13: sent reminder to respond to the authors. 2020-07-14: response received. 2020-07-16: response received. 2020-12-03: requested authors review updates to 2119/8174 text


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-protocol-19 (RFC-to-be 8847)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-23. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Presta Y 2020-08-14
S P. Romano Y 2020-08-14
Area Director: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-07-17
IANA N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-23: questions sent to authors. one item for the AD. 2020-07-17: AD approval received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-signaling-15 (RFC-to-be 8848)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-06. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Hanton Y 2020-08-24
P. Kyzivat Y 2020-09-03
L. Xiao Y 2020-08-26
C. Groves Y 2020-09-02
IANA Y 2020-09-08

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-06: questions sent to authors. 2020-07-07: response received. 2020-07-09: response received. 2020-07-14: response received. 2020-07-27: reminder to respond sent to authors. 2020-07-29: additional question sent to authors. 2020-08-05: reminder to respond sent to authors. 2020-08-12: reminder to respond sent to authors. 2020-08-20: reminder to respond sent to authors. 2020-08-21: response received. 2020-08-24: response received. 2020-08-26: response received. 2020-09-01: response received. 2020-09-02: response received. 2020-09-03: response received. 2020-09-04: asked IANA to update their registry with "m=" line [IANA #1177337]. 2020-09-08: IANA update complete. 2020-09-28: asked authors about updating mid value to be "mid" value


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-rtp-mapping-14 (RFC-to-be 8849)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-06. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
R. Even Y 2020-07-20
J. Lennox Y 2020-07-17
M. Kucherawy Y 2020-11-12
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-06: questions sent to authors. 2020-07-13: reminder to respond sent. 2020-07-14: response received. 2020-07-15: response received. 2020-07-17: response received. 2020-07-20: response received. 2020-07-28: moved this document from AUTH48-DONE to AUTH48 based on discussion with Murray. He indicated there may be a few changes coming. Added Murray as an approver so know to check in with him if we don't hear something before the rest of the cluster is ready for publication. 2020-10-08: moved this document to IESG state per Barry. 2020-11-12: implemented the update and moved this document back to AUTH48-DONE. Noted the AD's approval of the added text. 2020-11-19: Jonathan replied to 2119/8174 question [Note: updated emails for the authors: ron.even.tlv@gmail.com and jonathan.lennox@8x8.com.]


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-clue-datachannel-18 (RFC-to-be 8850)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-06-23. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-06-25
IANA N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-06-23: questions sent to author.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-rid-15 (RFC-to-be 8851)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-09. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
A.B. Roach, Ed. Y 2020-05-28

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-09: questions sent to author. 2020-05-21: reply received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-avtext-rid-09 (RFC-to-be 8852)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-09. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
A.B. Roach Y 2020-05-21
S. Nandakumar Y 2020-07-13
P. Thatcher Y 2020-08-10

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-09: questions sent to authors. 2020-05-21: reply received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-sdp-simulcast-14 (RFC-to-be 8853)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-09. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
B. Burman Y 2020-05-19
M. Westerlund Y 2020-05-28
S. Nandakumar Y 2020-05-22
M. Zanaty Y 2020-05-22
Area Director: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-05-18

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-09: questions sent to author. 2020-05-12: reply received. 2020-05-13: requested AD approval of changes.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rtcweb-fec-10 (RFC-to-be 8854)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-10. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
J. Uberti Y 2020-05-01

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-10 Questions sent to author 2020-04-20 Reminder sent 2020-04-27 Response received


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-bfcpbis-rfc4582bis-16 (RFC-to-be 8855)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
G. Camarillo Y 2020-05-07
K. Drage N  
T. Kristensen Y 2020-05-07
J. Ott Y 2020-05-07
C. Eckel Y 2020-05-06
AD - Murray Kucherawy or Barry Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to the authors. 2020-05-05: Eckel responded. 2020-05-06: document updated and Eckel approved. 2020-05-07: Camarillo, Kristensen, and Ott approved. 2020-05-13: reminder sent. 2020-05-19: Drage responded, document updated. 2020-06-02: reminder sent. 2020-06-15: reminder sent. 2020-06-23: reminder sent. 2020-07-13: reminder sent. 2020-08-26: reminder sent. 2020-09-14: reminder sent. 2020-09-28: updated document refs based on WG discussion. 2020-10-06: reminder sent. 2020-10-27: reminder sent. 2020-11-05: reminder sent. 2020-12-03: reminder sent. 2020-12-03: asked ADs to approve change to keyword and update to using 8174-defined keywords paragraph 2020-12-03: Kucherawry, Eckel, Kristensen approved keyword change 2020-12-04: Camarillo approved keyword change


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-bfcpbis-rfc4583bis-27 (RFC-to-be 8856)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
G. Camarillo Y 2020-06-02
T. Kristensen Y 2020-06-02
C. Holmberg Y 2020-05-18
AD (Murray Kucherawy) Y 2020-05-05
IANA Y 2020-06-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to the authors. 2020-05-05: Requested AD approval of update to Section 4, to make sure it's not "beyond editorial." 2020-05-05: AD approval received. 2020-06-03: IANA updates completed and OK until after PUB.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-bfcpbis-bfcp-websocket-15 (RFC-to-be 8857)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-05-04. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
V. Pascual Y 2020-05-14
A. Román Y 2020-05-14
S. Cazeaux Y 2020-05-14
G. Salgueiro Y 2020-05-07
R. Ravindranath Y 2020-05-07
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) Y 2020-12-03

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-05-04: questions sent to the authors 2020-05-13: reminder sent 2020-12-03: author replied to request to review 2119/8174 update 2020-12-03: Kucherawy, Pascual, Román approved 2119/8174 update


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-mux-exclusive-12 (RFC-to-be 8858)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-05-06
AD: M. Kucherawy or B. Leiba (2119/8174) N  

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-20: questions sent to author. 2020-04-21: reply received. 2020-12-03: Christer approved use of RFC 8174 keywords paragraph


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-sdp-mux-attributes-19 (RFC-to-be 8859)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-04-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
S. Nandakumar Y 2020-08-28
Area Director: M. Kucherawy Y 2020-09-01
IANA update Y 2020-09-22

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-04-20: questions sent to author. 2020-04-21: additional questions sent to author. 2020-05-09: reply received. 2020-05-12: checked with Document Shepherd re: #18. 2020-05-13: requested AD approval of changes. 2020-05-18: requested that IANA make updates to the registry. 2020-05-18: IANA completed the requested updates. AD approved the changes. 2020-05-18: updated the document per mail from C. Holmberg. 2020-08-28: updated to match changes in draft-ietf-mmusic-sdp-mux-attributes-19. requested AD approval of more changes. 2020-08-28: received change from Paul Kyzivat. 2020-09-01: AD approved the changes. Drafted a second set of requested updates for IANA. [Did not send the requested updates, but the IANA registry was updated accordingly.] 2020-12-03: requested the author review 2119/8174 update


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-avtcore-multi-media-rtp-session-13 (RFC-to-be 8860)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-16. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
M. Westerlund Y 2020-09-28
C. Perkins Y 2020-09-22
J. Lennox Y 2020-09-22

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-16: questions sent to the authors


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-avtcore-rtp-multi-stream-optimisation-12 (RFC-to-be 8861)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-16. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
J. Lennox Y 2020-09-23
M. Westerlund Y 2020-09-23
Q. Wu Y 2020-08-09
C. Perkins Y 2020-09-22

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-16: questions sent to the authors


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-sipbrandy-rtpsec-08 (RFC-to-be 8862)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
J. Peterson Y 2020-09-27
R. Barnes Y 2020-10-08
R. Housley Y 2020-08-28
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-07-22

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-21: Requested AD approval of changes from "RECOMMENDS" to "SHOULD". 2020-07-22: AD approval received (includes guidance and approval re. RFCs 8838 and 8839).


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-ice-pac-06 (RFC-to-be 8863)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-07-21
J. Uberti Y 2020-07-24

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:


AUTH48 status of draft-ietf-mmusic-data-channel-sdpneg-28 (RFC-to-be 8864)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-22. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
K. Drage N  
M. Makaraju Y 2020-10-24
R. Ejzak N  
J. Marcon N  
R. Even, Ed. Y 2020-10-01
AD: Murray Kucherawy Y 2020-09-14

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-22: questions sent to authors. 2020-08-18: Requested AD approval of removal of last paragraph in Section 5.2.1 (which contains "RFC 2119" language). 2020-08-18: AD approval received. 2020-09-14: Requested AD approval for removal of a "MAY" and a "MUST" in Section 5.2. 2020-09-14: AD approval received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-t140-usage-data-channel-14 (RFC-to-be 8865)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-22. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
C. Holmberg Y 2020-09-15
G. Hellström Y 2020-07-24

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-22: questions sent to authors.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-rfc4566bis-37 (RFC-to-be 8866)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-13. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
A. Begen Y 2020-09-23
P. Kyzivat Y 2020-09-05
C. Perkins Y 2020-08-31
M. Handley Y 2020-10-28

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-13: questions sent to authors. 2020-07-15: response received from author. 2020-07-17: response received from author. 2020-07-18: response received from author. 2020-07-21: response received from author. 2020-07-22: response received from author. 2020-07-24: response received from author. 2020-07-27: response received from author. 2020-07-28: response received from author. 2020-08-26: response received from author. 2020-08-31: response received from author, approval received. 2020-09-01: response received from authors. 2020-09-02: response received from authors. 2020-09-03: response received from author. 2020-09-05: approval received. 2020-09-21: reminder sent to authors. 2020-09-23: approval received. 2020-09-28: reminder sent to author. 2020-10-06: reminder sent to author. 2020-10-27: reminder sent to author. 2020-10-28: all approvals received.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rmcat-eval-test-10 (RFC-to-be 8867)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
Z. Sarker Y 2020-07-23
V. Singh Y 2020-07-22
X. Zhu Y 2020-07-22
M. Ramalho Y 2020-07-23

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-20: questions sent to authors.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rmcat-eval-criteria-14 (RFC-to-be 8868)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
V. Singh Y 2020-07-29
J. Ott Y 2020-07-29
S. Holmer Y 2020-08-27

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-20: questions sent to authors. 2020-08-05: reminder sent. 2020-08-16: reminder sent. 2020-08-26: reminder sent.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-rmcat-wireless-tests-11 (RFC-to-be 8869)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-07-20. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
Z. Sarker Y 2020-07-25
X. Zhu Y 2020-07-24
J. Fu Y 2020-07-26

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-07-20: questions sent to authors.


AUTH48-DONE status of draft-ietf-mmusic-msrp-usage-data-channel-24 (RFC-to-be 8873)

This document is in AUTH48 state as of 2020-11-18. It has not yet been published as an RFC. The RFC Editor is awaiting approvals from the author(s) as shown below (and anyone else listed) before continuing the publication process.

Name Approved? Date of Approval
JM. Recio, Ed. Y 2020-11-24
C. Holmberg Y 2020-11-24
AD - B. Leiba or M. Kucherawy Y 2020-11-24

** This document is part of Cluster C238, so may have additional holds before publication.

Notes:

2020-11-18: Questions sent to authors. 2020-11-19: Updated XML received from Recio, feedback incorporated. 2020-11-23: Feedback received from Holmberg, feedback incorporated. 2020-11-24: Question to AD regarding term updates. 2020-11-24: Kucherawy approved updates.


Instructions to author(s):

Please see the AUTH48 notification email from the RFC Editor that contains links to the edited files and other information. To send your approval of or changes for a specific document, please Reply All to the message for the given RFC-to-be in question.

If cluster-wide questions were received, please Reply All to that email so each of the relevant parties may partake in the decision process.

See information below for the status of documents within the cluster that are in AUTH48.

When all approvals for a given document have been received, publication will continue once its normative references have completed the AUTH48 process as well. Upon publication of the cluster, this AUTH48 status page will no longer be available.