[rfc-i] REOC membership

Bob Hinden bob.hinden at gmail.com
Wed Jan 26 16:19:20 PST 2011


Dave,

>>> 
>>> Since the IAB is the appeal body for REOC decisions, there is already a built-in
>> way to resolve severe conflict.  Therefore, I do not think we should go out of
>> our way to exclude anyone.  We have already had a situation where IAOC
>> members have held other I* seats.  No conflict surfaced.  Had there been an
>> appeal of anIAOC decision to the other body, that dual-hatted person would
>> have to recuse.  Not a big deal.
>>> 
>> 
>> +1
> 
> +1 
> 
> My issue with such a restriction has always been that the IAB itself is a stream-
> approving body, and the REOC should be a committee/Program organized by
> the IAB.   Saying that IAB members must not be part of the REOC doesn't
> seem to be solving any problem.

+1

Bob





More information about the rfc-interest mailing list