Simplified FSM For Independent Submission Review (ISR) Process Independent Submission to Independent Submissions Editor | | V Author 2----------+ 1----------------+ revise | | | |------------>| ISR-AUTH | t/o | ISR-INIT |<----------- | revise |----> DNP |(Initial review)| Revision +----------+ | | +<----------| |<-----------------+ +-------> DNP | Fail +----------------+ Disagree | |Agree/ignore | | Early | ^ 5----------+ | OK | IESG | | "OK" |IAB Appeal| | | ReviewV | +----------+ | | 3------------+ ^Author | | | TO state | |appeal | | |(IESG review|"Conflict" 4------------+ | | | per 5742) |---------->| ISR-AP-WAIT| | | +------------+ +------------+ | V | | 6------------------+ |t/o | | | V | +--->| ISR-FINDR | DNP | ^ | (Find reviewer) | | | +------------------+ | | ^ | ^ KEY: | |Auth |Need new | |t/o t/o: Timeout | |Request|Review V | DNP: Do not publish | |New | 7----------------+ | |Review | | | | | | | ISR-R-WAIT |<--------+ | | | | (Await review) | | | | | | | |Revision | | | +----------------+ | | | | | Review done | | | | V 9----------+ | | 8------------------+ Author | | t/o | | | | revise | ISR-AUTH |-----> DNP | | | ISR-EVAL | ----------->| revise | | | | (ISE evaluate | +----------+ | | | reviews) |<------------------+ +--------> DNP | | | | Disagree | |Agree/ignore | | +------------------+ 13---------+ | | | | ^ | |IAB Appeal| | | Reject| | IESG | |"OK" +----------+ V | V | review| V ^Author 10---------------+ | 11-----------+ |appeal | ISR-AU-WAIT | | | TO state | | +----------------+ | |(IESG review|"Conflict" 12-----------+ | | | per 5742) |---------->| ISR-AP-WAIT| t/o| | +------------+ +------------+ | | t/o| V V V DNP EDIT State DNP 13 October 2022